Rail Users Ireland Forum

Rail Users Ireland Forum (http://www.railusers.ie/forum/index.php)
-   Galway - Limerick - Waterford - Rosslare (http://www.railusers.ie/forum/forumdisplay.php?f=55)
-   -   Galway-Limerick intermediate timetable (http://www.railusers.ie/forum/showthread.php?t=12050)

Colm Moore 11-02-2010 10:16

Galway-Limerick intermediate timetable
 
Did someone have a timetable for the intermediate stations from Galway-Limerick? I know that Galway, Athenry and Ennis-Limerick are listed publicly.

comcor 11-02-2010 10:29

Sixmilebridge is listed in the Dublin-Limerick/Ennis timetable

http://www.irishrail.ie/your_journey...erick%2010.pdf

comcor 12-02-2010 11:59

A day after this thread appears here, a timetable appears on the Irish Rail website...

http://www.irishrail.ie/your_journey...alway%2010.pdf

newbahn 12-02-2010 14:33

Guys,

Sorry this may be a silly question but is the journey time on this route not really slow???

Mark Gleeson 12-02-2010 14:44

Of course its slow, but no one listened when everyone was saying that as apparently it was anti west of Ireland.

finnyus 12-02-2010 14:51

Quote:

Originally Posted by comcor (Post 53841)
A day after this thread appears here, a timetable appears on the Irish Rail website...

http://www.irishrail.ie/your_journey...alway%2010.pdf

Anyone know what current passenger numbers are like for the 06:45 Ennis - Limerick? If this is well used, could I.E. not start the service from Gort? 06:15 Gort - Limerick. This would require the 06:00 Limerick - Galway service to start at least 30 minutes earlier. 08:39 arrival into Limerick is not the best arrival time into Limerick from stations north of Ennis for commuters (including students) - they still have to get from Colbert Station!

I know comparing the WRC and the Midleton line, is possibly like comparing chalk and cheese, due to population density, etc... BUT Midleton's initial service frequency (including arrival times in to Kent station) are one of the factors of its success (others being clockface timetable).

For a lot of people, the WRC will be a new service (not having experienced the last train services on the WRC). How can five services a day and this timetable make anyone want to get out of their cars?

Commuters need some form of flexibility: Someone commuting from Gort to Limerick everyday decides to take the train - the need to make sure that work/college times are within 08:39 - 18:05, otherwise the train is no use to them - flexitime does not seem to be part of I.E.

I am very much pro-rail, unfortunately I.E. does not seem to see the possible potential of this new line.

finnyus 12-02-2010 14:59

Quote:

Originally Posted by newbahn (Post 53843)
Guys,

Sorry this may be a silly question but is the journey time on this route not really slow???

Ennis - Gort by rail is ~20miles (its not more than 20 miles) and takes 28 minutes - speed: 43 miles per hour?

comcor 12-02-2010 16:17

The speeds are unbelievable really.

Aside from the 2 hours to get from Limerick to Galway, I've long thought that to be a success it would need to be part of a Galway-Limerick-Cork or Galway-Limerick-Waterford route. But the best times offered on these routes are 3 3/4 hours and 5 hours respectively. Both also involve 2 changes of train.

Between the speed and the lack of connectivity, you could get the impression that someone wants it to fail.

finnyus 12-02-2010 16:27

Quote:

Originally Posted by comcor (Post 53850)
Between the speed and the lack of connectivity, you could get the impression that someone wants it to fail.

Timetable is one justification of that!

Colm Moore 12-02-2010 17:03

Quote:

Originally Posted by finnyus (Post 53847)
Ennis - Gort by rail is ~20miles (its not more than 20 miles) and takes 28 minutes - speed: 43 miles per hour?

Quote:

Originally Posted by comcor (Post 53850)
The speeds are unbelievable really.

Aside from the 2 hours to get from Limerick to Galway, I've long thought that to be a success it would need to be part of a Galway-Limerick-Cork or Galway-Limerick-Waterford route. But the best times offered on these routes are 3 3/4 hours and 5 hours respectively. Both also involve 2 changes of train.

Between the speed and the lack of connectivity, you could get the impression that someone wants it to fail.

Even providing through services Galway-Limerick Junction would be a big improvement. While the WRC provides complimentary Galway-Cork connections, it doesn't make vast changes. I'm not sure if it makes any real difference to Galway-Waterford as it misses the morning Limerick Junction-Waterford train.

dowlingm 13-02-2010 20:39

IE spent 106m on the line to bring it back to 50mph. This was obviously a compromise figure between spending nothing and spending 200m or more to make sufficient improvements to safely operate at 60-75mph and retrofit those improvements to Ennis-Limerick. It's a political line, as long as it exists on a map the politicians have bought off the West.

Colm Moore 14-02-2010 18:07

Some of the line can only be described as undulating, whiles earthworks on a large scale can be relatively cheap, potentially one would have been into earthworks on a truly huge scale, involving buyin parts of surrounding fields.

Of course, it would avoid the problem of regular flooding.

dowlingm 14-02-2010 19:19

There is what looks like an elevation diagram in this picture (below the track map)

If that is what it looks like it bears out what Victor just said.

finnyus 16-02-2010 17:09

Gort, Ardrahan, Craughwell - Dublin Day Trips
 
Was just looking at the printed timetable of the Galway - Limerick services and the online journey planner for Athenry - Dublin services.

It also does not seem possible to make proper day trip to the capital with the Galway - Limerick timetable!

Note: In total, you are limited to 9 services to Dublin, 7 services to Gort.

Earliest train from Gort - Dublin: 07:32* (via Limerick) or 07:33 (via Athenry)
Latest train from Gort - Dublin: 15:21 (via Athenry) or 18:41* (via Limerick)

Earliest train from Dublin - Gort: 07:00 (via Limerick) or 07:30* (via Athenry)
Latest train from Dublin - Gort: 11:30 (via Athenry) or 15:25* (via Limerick)

* quicker option

Information
Gort to Dublin Possibilities:
  • via Athenry (Monday - Saturday)
    1. Dept Gort 07:33 - arr Athenry 08:05 (73mins wait) dept Athenry 09:18 - arr Dublin 11:47
      • Stats:
        • Total time: 4hrs 14mins
        • Total number of changes: 1
    2. Dept Gort 10:41 - arr Athenry 11:12 (6min transfer time) dept Athenry 11:18 - arr Dublin 13:40
      • Stats:
        • Total time: 2hrs 59mins
        • Total number of changes: 1
    3. Dept Gort 13:01 - arr Athenry 13:32 (106min transfer time) dept Athenry 15:18 - arr Dublin 17:47
      • Stats:
        • Total time: 4hrs 46mins
        • Total number of changes: 1
      • Note: Previous Dublin-bound train departed Athenry at 13:18 (14 minutes prior to the arrival of the train from Limerick)
      • Note: Previous Dublin-bound train (at 13:18) does not cross a Dublin to Galway train at Athenry at this time, so one platform is free at Athenry
    4. Dept Gort 15:21 - arr Athenry 15:52 (136min transfer time) dept Athenry 18:18 - arr Dublin 20:45
      • Stats:
        • Total time: 5hrs 24mins
        • Total number of changes: 1
    5. Dept Gort 19:11 - arr Athenry 19:42 (no same-day connection to Dublin - next train eastbound is the 22:28* to Athlone)
      • * 22:28 to Athlone is Monday - Friday only
  • via Limerick (Monday - Saturday)
    1. Dept Gort 07:32 - arr Limerick 08:39 (21min transfer time) dept Limerick 09:00 - arr Limerick Jctn 09:28 (6min transfer time) dept Limerick Jctn 09:34 - arr Dublin 11:15
      • Stats:
        • Total time: 3hrs 43mins
        • Total number of changes: 2
    2. Dept Gort 10:41 - arr Limerick 11:48 (12min transfer time) dept Limerick 12:00 - arr Limerick Jctn 12:27 (6min transfer time) dept Limerick Jctn 12:31 - arr Dublin 14:25
      • Stats:
        • Total time: 3hrs 44mins
        • Total number of changes: 2
    3. Dept Gort 13:01 - arr Limerick 14:08 (47min transfer time) dept Limerick 14:55 - arr Limerick Jctn 15:22 (11min transfer time) dept Limerick Jctn 15:33 - arr Dublin 17:20
      • Stats:
        • Total time: 4hrs 19mins
        • Total number of changes: 2
    4. Dept Gort 15:21 - arr Limerick 16:28 (27min transfer time) dept Limerick 16:55 - arr Limerick Jctn 17:22 (10min transfer time) dept Limerick Jctn 17:32 - arr Dublin 19:30
      • Stats:
        • Total time: 4hrs 9mins
        • Total number of changes: 2
    5. Dept Gort 18:41 - arr Limerick 19:24 (46min transfer time) dept Limerick 20:10 - arr Limerick Jctn 20:39 (51min transfer time) dept Limerick Jctn 21:30 - arr Dublin 23:23
      • Stats:
        • Total time: 4hrs 42mins
        • Total number of changes: 2

Dublin to Gort Possibilities:
  • via Athenry (Monday - Saturday)
    1. Dept Dublin 07:30 - arr Athenry 09:52 (11mins wait) dept Athenry 10:03 - arr Dublin 10:41
      • Stats:
        • Total time: 3hrs 11mins
        • Total number of changes: 1
    2. Dept Dublin 09:30 - arr Athenry 11:49 (37mins wait) dept Athenry 12:26 - arr Dublin 13:01
      • Stats:
        • Total time: 3hrs 31mins
        • Total number of changes: 1
    3. Dept Dublin 11:30 - arr Athenry 13:47 (59mins wait) dept Athenry 14:46 - arr Dublin 15:21
      • Stats:
        • Total time: 3hrs 51mins
        • Total number of changes: 1
    4. Dept Dublin 15:30 - arr Athenry 17:47 (no same-day connection to any station towards Limerick)
      • Note: Previous Athenry to Limerick train departed Athenry at 17:41 (6 minutes prior to the arrival of the train from Dublin)
      • Note: The 15:30 Dublin to Galway train does not cross a Galway to Dublin train at Athenry at this time, so one platform is free at Athenry
  • via Limerick (Monday - Saturday)
    1. Dept Dublin 07:00 - arr Limerick Jctn 08:44 (3min transfer time) dept Limerick Jctn 08:47 - arr Limerick 09:16 (19min transfer time) dept Limerick 09:35 - arr Gort 10:41
      • Stats:
        • Total time: 3hrs 41mins
        • Total number of changes: 2
    2. Dept Dublin 09:00 - arr Limerick Jctn 10:48 (2min transfer time) dept Limerick Jctn 10:50 - arr Limerick 11:19 (36min transfer time) dept Limerick 11:55 - arr Gort 13:01
      • Stats:
        • Total time: 4hrs 01mins
        • Total number of changes: 2
    3. Dept Dublin 12:00 - arr Limerick Jctn 13:41 (3min transfer time) dept Limerick Jctn 13:44 - arr Limerick 14:10 (5min transfer time) dept Limerick 14:15 - arr Gort 15:21
      • Stats:
        • Total time: 3hrs 21mins
        • Total number of changes: 2
    4. Dept Dublin 15:25 - arr Limerick 17:48 (17min transfer time) dept Limerick 18:05 - arr Gort 19:11
      • Stats:
        • Total time: 3hrs 46mins
        • Total number of changes: 2

Sunday Summary
  • via Athenry
    • 3ish connections available at Athenry to stations towards Limerick from
    • 14:30 Dublin - Galway misses the Limerick train at Athenry by 6 minutes. The 14:30 does not cross any train at Athenry at this time. Passengers on this train would need to wait 2+ hours at Athenry to get the 18:57 from Athenry to Limerick.
    • 3ish connections available from Limerick at Athenry for Dublin-bound trains
      trains originating in Dublin
      • transfer times at Athenry are ~40mins, ~60mins and ~30mins
  • via Limerick
    • 3 connections available from Limerick towards Athenry from trains originating in Dublin
      • transfer times at Limerick are between 17 and 25mins
    • 3 connections available at Limerick from stations towards Athenry for Dublin-bound trains
      • transfer times at Athenry are ~12mins, ~33mins and ~11mins

E & O E!

After reading this, I have concluded that I have too much time on my hands !

Colm Moore 16-02-2010 22:38

1 Attachment(s)
Quote:

Originally Posted by finnyus (Post 53899)
After reading this, I have concluded that I have too much time on my hands !

Then you'll be able to do the reverse timetable for services to Galway.

Colm Moore 16-02-2010 23:44

1 Attachment(s)
Map

finnyus 17-02-2010 08:17

Quote:

Originally Posted by Victor (Post 53902)
Then you'll be able to do the reverse timetable for services to Galway.

Full details of these can be found on the Galway - Limerick timetable.

Great excel timetable though! And you should submit the map to I.E. because the actual pixel quality of it is far better than the one on the I.E. website.

Colm Moore 17-02-2010 22:36

Quote:

Originally Posted by finnyus (Post 53904)
And you should submit the map to I.E. because the actual pixel quality of it is far better than the one on the I.E. website.

;)

Mark Gleeson 18-02-2010 00:05

There is some class of issue with the height and width trust me he has tried to get this sorted for ages but its never just right

lasno 05-03-2010 12:23

Tried to book online Limerick/Galway on March 31st. When I select train and hit "proceed to reservation" I get the following reply "Your selection cannot be purchased online. You have selected ticket only for all parts of the journey. A P (premier/first class) or S (standard) must be ticked for at least one part of the journey".
Now this service is operated by a railcar so only a ticket can be purchased.
They need to do some more maintenance on the website.
Also €28.50 each way seems a bit expensive.

Mark Gleeson 05-03-2010 12:37

That error is consistent, you cannot buy a ticket online unless there is a least one reservation leg, no trains on the WRC have reservations. Try Rosslare Dublin same situation

The fare is 28.50 is consistent with the default fares matrix for distance zone J (109-121 km) for the distance involved, as in the maximum fare IE are legally allowed charge

Going on the regional matrix Limerick Galway day return will be 20 euro, or 23 euro monthly return

finnyus 05-03-2010 12:58

Even at 20Euro, Limerick - Galway by train is very pricey compared to the bus services on the same route. Just take a look at the two operators on the route. Citylink have a Super Advance single ticket and even the twitter specials that Bus Eireann were offering up to the 28th Feb - great value! All specials were/are for outside of peak time services.

Next Tuesday I am going Cork - Galway with Citylink for 1 Euro each way.

Mark Gleeson 05-03-2010 13:03

I'm only quoting from the not so public matrix. Irish Rail can bend and twist it all they like but the revenue expectations are based on an assumption that the fares would be the same as the Limerick - Rosslare matrix.

lasno 05-03-2010 16:04

Thank you Mark for explaining the inner workings of Irish Rail.
Twenty Euro return would be an ok fare.

Jister 23-03-2010 18:37

What would the fares be does anybody know, or is there a link on irishrail.ie to show me?

SMB-Ennis RTN
SMB-Gort RTN
Ennis-Galway RTN
Ennis-gort RTN
SMB-Limk RTN
SMB-Galway RTN

Mark Gleeson 23-03-2010 19:25

Going on the regional fares matrix, these are the fares. Irish Rail of course are known to invent a new matrix when it suits so don't take these as gospel but they are the only numbers in public drawn from Irish Rail's own fares matrix. What I can tell you it is highly likely there will be no single tickets as is the practice on every other regional route.

As we have yet to get an exact milepost distance on Sixmilebridge it is hard to judge which distances are involved and therefore the zone

Galway Craughwell = 18.6 miles 29.9 km zone B
Galway Ardrahan = 24.6 miles 39.6km zone C
Galway Gort = 31.4 miles 50.2km zone E
Galway Ennis = 48.9 miles 78.7 km zone G
Galway Sixmilebridge = ?? zone H
Galway Limerick = 73.6 miles 118.4 km zone K

Limerick Sixmilebridge = ?? zone B
Limerick Gort = 42.3 miles 68 km zone F
Limerick Ardrahan = 49 miles 78.8 km zone G
Limerick Craughwell = 55 miles 88.5 km zone G
Limerick Athenry = 60.5 miles 97.3 km zone H

Ennis Gort 17.25 miles 27.8 km zone B
Ennis Athenry 35.5 miles 57.1 km zone F
Ennis Galway 48.6 miles 78.2 km zone G


Day returns
A 5.00
B 6.50
C 8.00
D 9.00
E 10.00
F 10.50
G 16.80
H 17.40
K 20.00

Jister 23-03-2010 20:23

Thanks for the fares.

Can't understand why there is no one way ticket. If I buy a return is it valid for a month and can I use it the same way twice?

They were busy painting the newly laid tar in SMB today. I thought it might not be ready but it looks good now.

Mark Gleeson 23-03-2010 20:41

Those are day return prices, I will post monthly return prices and monthly season ticket prices later. A return is valid for an outbound journey on the date of issue and return from destination on or before the expiry date, it cannot be used in the same direction twice

Please bear in mind these are best educated guesses we are waiting on IE to release the offical list

Thomas Ralph 23-03-2010 21:34

Strictly there is a single ticket, it just costs the same as the return ticket :rolleyes:

Mark Gleeson 23-03-2010 22:20

For Limerick Rosslare there is no single ticket code (last page of this pdf http://www.railusers.ie/reports/2008...1_appendix.pdf) unlike some other routes where there is a distinct single and return code but same price.

I'll set to work on monthly return fares (before anyone asks there is no zone I)

Month Season Ticket
A 84.00
B 123.00
C 133.00
D 177.00
E 193.00
F 244.00
G 259.00
H 270.00
K 360.00

Brian.Stokes 23-03-2010 23:56

Was recently asked about Sixmilebridge fares and was given the below when I asked.

From Sixmilebridge to Limerick
Adult Day Return €11
Student Day Return €9.20
5 Day Student Weekly Return €26.50
Monthly Adult Return €123
Monthly Student Return €86

Mark Gleeson 24-03-2010 07:45

Those numbers are very strange, the monthly ones are right but the others don't look right

For instance there is no such thing as a student day return, all student returns are valid for 31 days

Thomas Ralph 24-03-2010 09:23

Nor is there a "5 day student weekly return", although that might possibly refer to a scholar ticket.

Mark Gleeson 24-03-2010 09:28

Quote:

Originally Posted by Thomas Ralph (Post 54618)
Nor is there a "5 day student weekly return", although that might possibly refer to a scholar ticket.

Which only exist in the Dublin short hop zone. Me thinks this is the usual Irish Rail not having made a plan yet and since Sixmilebridge is between Limerick and Ennis it is currently on the high price matrix

The tickets available are
Day saver return
Monthly saver return
Student single/monthly return
Adult/Child/Student weekly/monthly

Note in some cases due to the strange way Irish Rail handle pricing that a weekly ticket is of no use at all

Brian.Stokes 24-03-2010 11:00

Well I rang Irish Rail in Limerick, they spent a few minutes pulling up the document and thats what I got kids. Did anyone actually ring Irish Rail yet and ask them?

Mark Gleeson 24-03-2010 11:19

We have asked for details to be made public, though I'd guess the fares are only being finalised this week. The list doesn't match with Irish Rail's family of ticket options.

If the staff in Limerick are asking their ticket machine it is likely to be wrong. If the day return fare Limerick Sixmilebridge is really 11 euro we might was well give up

If I was a betting man I'd try the ticket vending machine in Limerick on Saturday morning, it will get a software update on Friday which might reveal the truth

Based on IE's numbers its clearly zone B to Sixmilebridge, the maximum approved fares are taking a zone B distance journey elsewhere http://www.railusers.ie/passenger_in... stage1=Submit

Mark Gleeson 24-03-2010 16:41

I can confirm it is 20 euro day return Galway Limerick

neoncircles 24-03-2010 20:08

11 Euro Lmk-SMB would be strange, seeing as its 11.60 or something day return Lmk-Ennis last time I used it- for half the distance it should be half the price more or less!

The bus is only 6.20 day return.

Jister 25-03-2010 13:13

Quote:

Originally Posted by neoncircles (Post 54639)
11 Euro Lmk-SMB would be strange, seeing as its 11.60 or something day return Lmk-Ennis last time I used it- for half the distance it should be half the price more or less!

The bus is only 6.20 day return.

There was about 10 people waiting for the bus yesterday in SMB around 11 o'clock, so not commuters. For anybody who knows it the bus service in SMB is rubbish, as it meanders under many nasty railway bridges. Its also infrequent as most services go Limerick - Shannon direct. The train should be able to hoover up all these passengers if the fares are right, as the service is going to be much more frequent.

dowlingm 26-03-2010 02:47

Yeah, but what if BE respond? Do they have the right to increase frequency without asking DoT first?


All times are GMT. The time now is 10:00.

Powered by vBulletin
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.